Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Introduction to our project

Welcome, Middle School ESOL Ts! We are going to attempt to blog our insights and opinions about our book, When English Language Learners Write, by Katharine Samway. In our Nov 11 CP meeting, we decided that we would skip Chapter 1, because it is a little redundant for those of us in the field. However, p.18-20 has some good info regarding Writing Research and policy. So, let's read those and take a look at Chapter 2, which includes oral/written connections, what ELLs can do before they are fluent in English, and the role of native language in their writing development (which we probably already have a few notions about, but we could share this with our faculties!). How about let's read a little and post a little and finish Chapter 2 by the end of Thanksgiving? What say ye?

4 comments:

  1. Happy Post Thanksgiving, Everyone! I hope you all had a wonderful celebration. Counting down 'til Christmas break, of course, but in the meantime, does anyone have any comments or points you'd like to make about our book? I found the comments in the end of Chapter 1 pretty interesting. Any takers?

    ReplyDelete
  2. HOla,

    I just got a copy of the book today.
    I have taken a few minutes to look over chapter two. I didn't see as many middle school examples as I would have liked.
    Most of the information offered was well known and not that evocative. How could anyone challenge the notion that writing should be personally meaningful to the student, or that the native language would influence their learning a second language.
    Yes we have all seen that they can learn to write before they have mastered the second language. Perhaps Samway can offer is to reinforce these conclusions that we as folks who work with these kids see daily.
    I am hoping that Samway will offer depth and advice that we can actually use in the coming chapters.

    Jerbo out

    ReplyDelete
  3. I highlighted the part about "resist the allure of overly simplified and misconstrued views of the writing process..." I have enjoyed watching my students go through the messy process of writing with sticky notes. It has been fun to see them think and organize their ideas.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I've gone back and reread these older comments, and I have to admit that I agree with Jerry! Many of the examples are too elementary, and much of the information is common sense. However, we can be confirmed that we must be knowledgeable about our subject!

    ReplyDelete