Monday, February 1, 2010

chapter 4 Gender, Race, Ethnicity, Social Class and Writing

Chapter four was a depressing chapter to read. It had good information, but reading it made me realize that teachers are biased when grading writing. Research by Peterson in 1998 reports that if a teacher thinks a girl is the writer, that response to the writing will be more positive. The fact that gender bias is still an issue is troubling. If this is still true, how will ESOL students ever get a fair shot when it comes to evaluating their writing and grading writing improvement? Katherine Davies Samway writes that student writing is “assessed in a language in which they are not fluent and then they suffer the long-term consequences of invalid results.” Additionally, she writes that too few teachers “mediate the cultural differences [among ESOL learners] and children are seen as problems, their home lives as disadvantaged, and their parents neglectful.”
Despite the problems with helping ESOL writers, Samway makes suggestions for good teaching. Home visits enable teachers to understand the challenges of the ELL writer. Samway suggests, “Culturally inclusive learning experiences, small group book discussions that include books in which each student can see himself, and writing for others (not just the teacher)” should be an integral part of literacy learning. “Authentic writing opportunities and audiences and multi-modal writing experiences to integrate oral, visual, and print literacies” must also be included in the learner’s tasks to promote better writing, according to Samway.
I see some classrooms where the ELL writer is nurtured. But, if all classroom teachers are to help ESOL writers, ESOL teachers have a lot of bridges to build in helping them understand how to better teach our students.

Samway, Katherine Davies. When English Language Learners Write. Heinemann Portsmouth, NH, 2006.

No comments:

Post a Comment