Hi, Folks! Did anyone have a chance to form any opinions yet? Does anyone have anything to share from the chart on p. 21? Do you agree that ELLs can write before they master English? So many of the observations stated seem to be more or less "Duh!" statements, but this is probably because we work with these students every day. I suppose if I were a mainstream teacher and had ELLs for the first time, perhaps I'd assume that they couldn't write at all. But, for example, shouldn't we just expect that "when children write on a topic that is of importance and interest to them, their writing is often better developed than writing in which they are less invested??????" (p.45) P.48 talks about how students incorporate their own language into English if they aren't sure exactly about what the rule in English would be but also how they do learn quickly to differentiate between the two systems easily. This goes right along with Krashen...
As normal for this global learner, I found some of the studies tedious and wanted to skip ahead to the results of these experiments. No surprises for us ESOL Ts....I like what they say on p.60 about writing experiences should not be worksheets that focus on the component parts of English writing but should be opportunities to express thoughts and emotions...written for an authentic audience...and with authentic purposes!
ANY TAKERS?
Friday, December 4, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I think the chart on page 21 would be interesting to give to the classroom teachers at the beginning of the year as a springboard for discussion. Last year at NPES, we did a school-based book study on writing, so it will be interesting to see how this book compares.
ReplyDelete