Tuesday, December 8, 2009

The second chapter of the book confirms my thinking on how ELL's write. The parts that I found particulary inspiring were about collaborative writing and sharing writing. The example on page 57 about Pablo struggling in solitary writing assignments yet thriving in collabortive efforts made me wonder how students who are not yet able to write independently will manage the PASS and HSAP tests. The text noted that no two writers are the same in their writing styles and development of writing skills. Of course we as ESOL teachers will have to continue to get all students to be able to write independently. But, what about the Pablo writers? How do we get them to write in an independent setting?
The sharing of writing always brings students attention to their writing products. Reading stories and essays aloud is a method that I wish more classroom teachers would embrace. Students are often unabashedly proud of their stories and are eager to share them.
Like Carla, I found myself rushing through parts of the chapter that seemed evident before I read them, but all teachers with experience realize that writers emerge. However, it seems to be a good account of research on ELL writing.
Thanks for reading, ya'll.

2 comments:

  1. I think the survey on page 21 should be given to all of our mainstream teachers. It could help them become aware of the assumptions that we often bring to the classroom about our ESOL students. Maybe I'll try this next year...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Chapter 2 Reflections

    I enjoyed examining the writing samples in chapter 2 and comparing them to my own students’ writings. The research done by Edelsky and Jilbert (1985) that concluded that bilingualism is an asset, and not a liability, is interesting information. This information may be useful to share with the classroom teachers to help them more fully understand the ELLs’ writing abilities.

    My experience is that collaborative activities such as writing workshops are beneficial for ALL students. Modeling is a key component, and I am a strong advocate of Michael Clay Thompson’s idea on using literature to teach not only grammar but writing.

    ReplyDelete