Happy New Year, Everyone! Welcome back to school, real life, and our book study. I honestly can't remember what I'd suggested in the pre-holiday email, but I'm thinking it was to try to read Chapter 3 by this Friday. So....If you've had a chance to do that, can you comment on the ideas of 1)choosing a topic for writing, 2)the impact of teachers' actions, 3)helping students understand the writing task and writing expectations (as in for ELDA and PASS), and/or 4)teaching the words, expressions and grammatical structures our students seem to be demonstrating a need for as opposed to randomly selecting isolated writing assignments? Any personal experiences you'd like to share?
Any or all of the above are welcomed...
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This chapter is hitting close to home as I have a student who chooses not to write independently. The ELA teacher spends most of our conversations discussing how he will not write in journals for her. Even when I "tweek" the topic, it takes some one-on-one discussion to get him to verbalize his ideas. It is a challenge, but this chapter encouraged me that if we persist, we will see progress.
ReplyDeleteI would like to comment on the impact of teachers' actions. As previous folks have commented, so far most of what I have read in this book seems to be common sense. Well maybe common sense to us. Lately I have been fighting the battle of how important the learning environment is for a couple of my level 1 students. Teachers do not understand "why the students don't work harder" or "why the students seem so apathetic"--"they are not going to get to high school if their skills don't improve and their MAP scores don’t go up...." Well Duh! Could it be the tests are in ENGLISH!
ReplyDeleteOkay--so now that I have gotten that of my mind...YES, the learning environment is important in learning anything--why have some teachers forgotten that--or did they ever learn this???? One of the most interesting points in chapter 3 for me is that "writing development isn't linear" and that sometimes children seem to regress in their development. I believe this information is valuable to share with teachers; I wonder if the same can be said about the development of reading skills and ELL students—my guess is probably.
I, too, wish there were more examples in this book of older students.